Best Pizza in Scottsdale: 5 Authentic Spots (2025)

Looking for the best pizza in Scottsdale that’ll actually blow your mind?

Here’s the deal:

Scottsdale’s pizza scene has exploded beyond chain restaurants. Local pizzerias are now crafting authentic, wood-fired pies that rival anything you’d find in Naples or New York—and we’re not exaggerating.

After eating our way through dozens of pizzerias (tough job, but someone had to do it), we’ve identified the five spots serving Scottsdale’s most mouthwatering slices. These aren’t your typical delivery joints—these are craft pizzerias where owners import ovens from Italy, make fresh mozzarella daily, and obsess over every detail of the perfect pie.

From Neapolitan-style pizza cooked in 90 seconds at 950°F to award-winning pies that food critics rave about, this guide covers the authentic local favorites that keep Scottsdale’s pizza lovers coming back.

Ready to find your new favorite slice?

1. Crust Brothers Pizza – Scottsdale’s Highest-Rated Pizzeria

The Vibe: Award-winning neighborhood favorite with perfect ratings

With a staggering 5.0 rating on Yelp (from 850+ reviews), 4.9 on Google, and 4.9 on TripAdvisor, Crust Brothers Pizza has earned its spot as Scottsdale’s most beloved pizzeria. Featured on Arizona PBS and consistently praised by local food critics, this isn’t just hype—it’s the real deal.

What Makes It Special:

Crust Brothers crafts artisan wood-fired pizzas using a high-temperature oven that creates that perfect char-blistered crust. The attention to detail is remarkable: house-made dough with proper fermentation, premium ingredients sourced locally when possible, and pizzaioli who actually know their craft.

The pizzeria earned recognition from Arizona PBS and maintains near-perfect ratings across all platforms—a rare feat that speaks volumes about consistency and quality.

Must-Try Pies:

• Margherita: Classic done to perfection—showcases the quality of every ingredient
• Specialty White Pizzas: Creative combinations with premium cheeses
• Seasonal Specials: Rotating pizzas featuring local Arizona produce

Pro Tip: Crust Brothers gets packed during peak hours (especially weekends). Order ahead or arrive early to secure your spot. The popularity is well-deserved—expect a wait if you show up during prime dinner time.

🔥 Try Crust Brothers Pizza →

2. LAMP Pizzeria – North Scottsdale’s Hidden Gem

The Vibe: Neighborhood pizzeria meets artisan craft

Starting with casual backyard pizza oven sessions, LAMP (Lindsay and Matt Pilato) has evolved into one of Scottsdale’s most beloved pizzerias with a 4.5-star rating across 1,346 reviews. Located in a North Scottsdale strip mall, don’t let the humble exterior fool you—this place is mighty.

What Makes It Special:

Matt Pilato employs ultra-long fermentations (24+ hours) to develop deep crust flavor and makes his own mozzarella from scratch. The result? Pizza with serious chew, bready depth, and surprising lightness that food critics call “among Arizona’s greats.”

The wood-fired oven reaches 800°F using oak and pecan wood, creating that perfect char-blistered crust that Neapolitan pizza lovers crave.

Must-Try Pies:

• Rapini Pizza: Broccoli rabe, pine nuts, chiles—artfully balanced with a kick
• Gepetto: Italian sausage, gorgonzola, onion marmalade. Spellbinding combination that’s become legendary
• Mignulata: A rich Sicilian bread stuffed with sausage and cauliflower (technically not pizza but you NEED to try it)

The Details:

With a cozy interior, intimate bar, and enchanting patio, LAMP creates memorable experiences. The pizzeria earned a 4.5-star rating on Tripadvisor and was featured on Arizona PBS’s “Check, Please! Arizona.”

Pro Tip: No reservations accepted. Arrive early or expect a wait—locals pack this place, especially on weekends. The Gepetto pizza is their signature—don’t leave without trying it.

🔥 Visit LAMP Pizzeria →

3. IL Bosco Pizza – Rustic Wood-Fired Excellence

The Vibe: Cozy neighborhood spot with Italian authenticity

Opening in May 2012 on a quiet road just northwest of Scottsdale Road & Shea Blvd, IL Bosco has built a loyal following with its dedication to natural ingredients and artisanal techniques. With a 4.5-star rating across 1,409 reviews, this pizzeria delivers consistent quality.

What Makes It Special:

Using only the best and natural ingredients, IL Bosco’s pizzas cook in a 900-degree Valoriani wood-fired oven. Every pizza is hand-made and topped with fresh imported cheeses, house-made sauces, and seasonal veggies and meats.

The aroma of crusty artisanal pizza cooking in that Italian oven will awaken your senses before you even sit down.

Must-Try Pies:

• Margherita: Simple perfection that showcases the quality of ingredients
• Burrata Special: Features roasted seasonal vegetables with creamy burrata cheese
• Calabrese: Spicy option with premium Italian meats

The Details:

IL Bosco maintains high ratings across Yelp and Tripadvisor with diners praising the authentic wood-fired flavor and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant offers a select list of wines by glass or bottle, beer on tap, and crafted cocktails to complement your dining experience.

Pro Tip: Happy Hour runs Monday-Friday from 4pm-5:30pm. The traditional Caprese salad with homemade pesto is a perfect starter. Multiple locations across the Valley, but the original Scottsdale spot on Becker Lane maintains that intimate neighborhood pizzeria vibe.

🔥 Try IL Bosco Pizza →

4. Craft 64 – Old Town’s Wood-Fired Powerhouse

The Vibe: Pizza meets craft beer paradise

After slinging pies in an Old Town adobe structure for nearly a decade, Craft 64 has become a Scottsdale staple with 2,405 reviews averaging 4.5 stars. This isn’t just a pizzeria—it’s a craft beer destination with 36 tap handles featuring exclusively Arizona brews.

What Makes It Special:

Craft 64 makes Neapolitan-ish style pizza using a wood-fired Mugnaini oven imported from Italy that flirts with 1,000 degrees. The mozzarella is handmade daily. Fresh produce comes from local purveyor McClendon’s Select.

The pizzeria earned recognition as a Top 50 Pizzeria in the USA by 50 Top Pizza for four consecutive years (2022-2025).

Must-Try Pies:

• Smokehouse: Smoked sausage, smoked onions, wine-braised mushrooms steal the show
• Aji: Made with house habanero sauce, fennel sausage, and topped with fresh spinach (for those who like heat)
• Specialty Focaccias: Especially the one topped with meatballs—the menu’s dark horse

The Details:

Airy, hefty, char-blistered pies emerge from that Italian oven with perfectly balanced toppings. The back patio is perfect for enjoying your pizza on a nice Arizona evening, and the craft beer selection is unmatched in Old Town.

Pro Tip: Check out their house-brewed beers, including their flagship IPA “Smooove Hoperator.” The summer special (pizza, salad, and two drinks for around $20) is an incredible value. Dog-friendly patio makes this a local favorite.

🔥 Visit Craft 64 →

5. Pomo Pizzeria Napoletana – Arizona’s Only VPN Certified Pizzeria

The Vibe: Authentic Neapolitan experience with upscale energy

Owner Stefano Fabbri brings his family’s 74-year Italian restaurant heritage to Scottsdale. Pomo is the first and only pizzeria in Arizona certified by both APN (Associazione Pizzaiuoli Napoletani) and VPN (Verace Pizza Napoletana) as authentic Neapolitan pizza.

That’s not marketing fluff—these are prestigious certifications from Naples-based pizza associations that verify you’re getting the real deal.

What Makes It Special:

The 6,000-pound wood-fired oven was built in Naples by a third-generation craftsman and shipped across the Atlantic Ocean. Pizzas are hand-tossed and cooked for just 60-90 seconds at 950°F, locking in flavors, natural aroma, and moisture.

The dough consists of imported organic “00” flour from Molino Caputo in Naples, natural yeast, Mediterranean sea salt, and undergoes a minimum 24-hour fermentation process.

Must-Try Pies:

• Rosso Margherita: Classic with diced fresh tomatoes—showcases the technique
• Bufala Verace: Made with real buffalo mozzarella imported from Italy
• Toto Sapore: Unique combination that highlights Stefano’s Rimini-style influences

The Details:

Pomo isn’t just about pizza—the fresh house-made pastas (including that last-meal-worthy lasagna) and antipasti are exceptional. The 4.8-star OpenTable rating (from 2,200+ reviews) speaks volumes.

Expect a lively, energetic atmosphere with a neighborhood trattoria feel. The pizza has that characteristic soft, slightly wet center that’s authentic to Neapolitan style—if you’re used to crispy American pizza, this might surprise you at first, but it’s exactly how they make it in Naples.

Pro Tip: Try the house-made gelato from Luna Gelato next door for dessert. Also, check if Stefano’s available—he loves chatting with guests about authentic Italian cuisine. Pet-friendly patio available.

🔥 Reserve at Pomo →

What Makes Scottsdale’s Pizza Scene Special?

Scottsdale’s pizza landscape offers something unique: authentic Italian techniques meeting Arizona’s farm-fresh ingredients and innovative spirit.

Here’s what sets these pizzerias apart:

Authentic Italian Ovens: These aren’t standard commercial pizza ovens. Crust Brothers, LAMP, Craft 64, Pomo, and IL Bosco all use Italian-made wood-fired ovens reaching 900-1000°F, creating that signature char and perfect crust.

House-Made Everything: From fresh mozzarella pulled daily to naturally fermented dough that rises for 24+ hours, these pizzerias obsess over quality. No shortcuts.

Local Sourcing: Craft 64 uses McClendon’s Select produce. Pomo sources from Arizona farms. The commitment to fresh, local ingredients elevates every bite.

Certified Excellence: Pomo holds prestigious VPN and APN certifications from Naples. Craft 64 earned Top 50 Pizzeria in the USA recognition four years running. Crust Brothers maintains perfect 5.0 ratings. LAMP was featured on Arizona PBS for culinary excellence.

Quick Pizza Comparison Guide

Pizza Etiquette: Neapolitan vs. American Style

If you’re trying authentic Neapolitan pizza for the first time, here’s what to expect:

Neapolitan Characteristics:

• Soft, slightly wet center (this is authentic—not undercooked)
• Delicate, foldable slices
• Eaten with fork and knife in Naples (though hands work too)
• Best enjoyed fresh from the oven

American/New York Style:

• Crispy throughout
• Firm slices that hold their shape
• Designed to be eaten by hand
• Travels well for takeout

Both styles are delicious—just different techniques with centuries of tradition behind them.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pizza in Scottsdale?

The best pizza in Scottsdale is Crust Brothers Pizza, which holds a perfect 5.0 rating on Yelp from 850+ reviews, 4.9 on Google, and 4.9 on TripAdvisor. For authentic Neapolitan style, Pomo (VPN certified) and LAMP Pizzeria offer exceptional quality. Craft 64 is unbeatable if you want craft beer pairing. All five pizzerias featured here consistently rank among Scottsdale’s top pizza destinations.

Where can I find wood-fired pizza in Scottsdale?

Crust Brothers, LAMP Pizzeria, Craft 64, Pomo, and IL Bosco all use authentic Italian wood-fired ovens reaching 900-1000°F. These ovens cook pizzas in 60-90 seconds, creating that signature char-blistered crust and wood-smoked flavor that defines artisan pizza.

What pizza in Scottsdale has the best reviews?

Crust Brothers Pizza has the highest ratings with 5.0 stars on Yelp, 4.9 on Google, and 4.9 on TripAdvisor (averaging 4.93 across 1,494 reviews). Pomo maintains a 4.8-star OpenTable rating from 2,200+ reviews. Craft 64 holds Top 50 Pizzeria in the USA recognition for four consecutive years (2022-2025).

Do any Scottsdale pizzerias make their own mozzarella?

Yes. LAMP Pizzeria, Craft 64, and Pomo all make fresh mozzarella daily. This commitment to house-made cheese dramatically improves flavor and texture compared to pre-made alternatives. Pomo even operates a mozzarella bar at their Forno Fabbri market concept.

Which Scottsdale pizza place is best for families?

Craft 64 in Old Town offers a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere with outdoor seating and a casual vibe. IL Bosco also caters to families with multiple locations and a comfortable neighborhood feel. Crust Brothers’ consistent quality makes it a hit with kids and adults alike.

Can I find gluten-free pizza in Scottsdale?

Absolutely. Crust Brothers, IL Bosco, LAMP Pizzeria, Craft 64, and Pomo all offer gluten-free crust options. LAMP specifically advertises “gluten-friendly” pizza. Many Scottsdale pizzerias now accommodate dietary restrictions—call ahead to confirm current offerings.

Where can I find vegan pizza in Scottsdale?

Craft 64, IL Bosco, and Pomo all offer vegan cheese options. Pomo is particularly noteworthy for offering vegan non-dairy cheese as part of their commitment to inclusivity. All three pizzerias can customize pizzas with plant-based toppings and dairy-free cheese substitutes. IL Bosco and Craft 64 explicitly list “vegan cheese available” in their dietary options.

Bottom Line: Where Should You Go?

After testing all five pizzerias, here’s our recommendation:

For the highest-rated experience: Start with Crust Brothers Pizza. That perfect 5.0 rating isn’t an accident—it’s the result of consistently excellent wood-fired pizza that keeps customers coming back. The quality speaks for itself.

For artisan Neapolitan craft: LAMP Pizzeria‘s 24-hour fermented doughs and house-made mozzarella create pizza that locals consider Arizona’s finest. The Gepetto pizza alone is worth the drive to North Scottsdale.

For authentic Italian Neapolitan: Pomo‘s VPN certification and Stefano Fabbri’s family heritage deliver the real deal. If you want pizza exactly like it’s made in Naples, this is your spot.

For pizza + craft beer paradise: Craft 64‘s combination of Top 50 USA recognition and 36 taps of Arizona craft beer makes it the perfect Old Town destination.

For rustic Italian neighborhood vibes: IL Bosco brings that cozy trattoria feel with consistently good wood-fired pizza at solid prices.

The truth? You can’t go wrong with any of these five pizzerias. Each offers something special, from Naples-certified authenticity to award-winning craft to perfect 5-star ratings.

Scottsdale’s pizza scene has matured into one of the Southwest’s best, proving that great pizza isn’t limited to New York or Chicago. These local pizzerias are crafting pies that would impress even the toughest Italian nonna.

Ready to explore more Scottsdale dining? Check out our guides to the Best Mexican Restaurants in Scottsdale Arizona for authentic tacos and margaritas, or discover the Best Steakhouses in Scottsdale for premium beef and fine dining.

After exploring pizza, don’t miss our guide to Best Brunch in Scottsdale for your morning dining adventures.